I fully oppose this guidance

This guidance includes potential discipline based on persistent use of incorrect pronouns.  It is quite literally impossible to know which pronouns someone prefers unless they decide to wear it on their shirt. There are also at least 7 different terms for gender identification in this document (definitions).  If you have to create a dictionary for people to understand what you are trying to convey then it is madness to even consider discipline based on the shifting sands of gender identity.


I strongly oppose!

I strongly oppose these transgender policies.  These policies will endanger all students not just the transgender students.  It will create a school environment that’s hostile towards faculty and students with deeply held religious and personal convictions on traditional definitions of sex and gender. This is too difficult for faculty to facilitate and not practical.  This will cause more confusion for the kids and teachers.  Teachers have enough to deal with on their hands.  The main focus for all schools is to educate the basics so they can be competent in reading, writing and math and history especially American history that is NOT based on critical race theory.


ALL NOTIONS OF TRANSGENDER SUPPORT IN EDUCATION ARE UNCONSTITUTIONAL

This policy clearly violates the 1st Amendment to the Constitution.  It amounts to law made by Congress and implemented through VDOE which DIS respects many if not all establishments of religion. This policy violates the 8th Amendment to the Constitution.  It leads children to a mode of existence that ultimately conflicts with their biological nature, leading to the cruel and unusual punishment of persons, who, having made ill-informed and ignorant choices as children, will be forced into situations from which they may never be able to retreat, which will destroy, prevent and twist the actualization of their natural talents and abilities towards the pursuit of happiness. This policy violates the 9th Amendment to the Constitution in that inevitably leads to situations wherein the rights of some members of the population will be denied and disparaged, e.g. rights of women to compete in sports without competition from men. This policy violates the 13th Amendment to the Constitution in that it creates and encourages a situation of involuntary servitude to a transgender existence. This policy violates the 14th Amendment to the Constitution in that it creates situation that ultimately deprive transgendered adults of their natural rights to unconstrained life and liberty to exist as a naturally sexed person. This policy confounds the terms of the 25th Amendment to the Constitution by creating a class of persons who can not be identified under the terms of this amendment, e.g.: the pronoun "his" and "he" are used seven times in this Amendment.  The import of this Amendment is vitiated by this policy's elimination of these terms from common parlance.  Before any such policy is created, an Amendment to the Constitution must be obtained to prevent the policy from vitiating this Amendment. The legal system of the United States abounds with distinctions based on identification by Sex.  No policy should be instituted which forces a change to the legal code of either State or Federal Government.  Changes to legal terminology should not be the product of educational policy but rather driven by top down legislative action, including first having amended to the Constitutions of each of the States and of the United States.. It is beyond the charter for the VDOE to institute policy which will change the underlying nature of any or all parallel and superior elements, systems, or agencies of government, commerce, science et al.  VDOE policy MUST be subordinate to the needs of all other departments so to "educate" to the needs of others.  This proposed policy is tantamount to an initiative by VDOE to undermine ALL other elements of government, commerce, religion et al in the State.  Such an initiative is UNCONSTITUTIONAL, and it is clearly OUT OF SCOPE for VDOE.


I do not support this!

Oppose transgender student policies.


all documents on self declaration of transgender and treatment of transgender .

I strongly oppose these documents on self declaration of transgender and treatment of transgender students A family is the first Institution ever formed and parental input and guidance is a first  for a child. Transgender is a world defined label with no legal or moral standing that needs a deep look at .  This will surely endanger all students. The implications and building up and forming the character of a child with such policies is horrendous mis-guiding  with far reaching adverse consequences to a future society.


Against all proposed policies

I’m thankful for the opportunity to offer a comment. These proposals bewildered me as a parent. As I looked at the names of contributors to these proposals I was shocked to see the names listed. I am writing as a parent. But these proposals should be concerning for anyone considering having children, who has children, or grandchildren. These proposals are a clear violation of parental rights. Why should the government be interfering in the parent-child relationship and hiding information from the parents? There must be clear evidence of abuse for that to occur and these proposals are clearly overstepping of the government’s role. It also sets a scary precedent for what the government may try to infiltrate. This is absolutely an area that the government has no basis for meddling in. The parent-child relationship ought to be unmeddled with. The importance of the parent-child relationship and the family unit is so strong that we have moved away from orphanages for those truly abused or alone and have placed those individuals in foster care. In a family unit. Because the parent (or acting parent) has the best understanding of their child’s needs. And as anyone who has served in the foster system can attest the government generally does a lousy job “helping” those children. Having a school staff member support a child through a gender change without the parents’ knowledge or consent is devastatingly destructive to that child and family. Overwhelming statistics show the incredibly high suicide rate for people who identify as transgender and then go through with hormone therapy/surgery. It’s obvious that continuing down the road of pursuing a transgender lifestyle is hurtful and destructive to that individual. A parent would have the child’s best interests at heart more than any unrelated staff member. No parent aware of the risks would willingly allow their child to be subjected to a pseudo-medical procedure that is statistically proven to increase the odds of confusion, regret, and suicidal thoughts for their child - for a lifetime. Stripping parents of their ability to protect their child from these hazards is an unprecedented violation of their rights, knowingly places children in harm’s way, and ignores numerous psychological studies.  I’m baffled that anyone would think these policies could save lives as other comments have suggested. That’s statistically untrue. Freedom of speech is infringed upon here too. There are some things that are just facts. The sky is blue. Say a teacher or student addresses a boy in the class as “he”, who decides they want to be addressed as a female (that hour, which may change 3 hours from now... as the proposal is written) and use the wrong pronoun for that moment. How can they be held accountable for that? The pronoun use is written completely arbitrarily in a way that asks to be abused by an angsty child with a disrespect for authority. Letting a child decide which dressing room to use on a whim is asking for all kinds of abusive scenarios. This is ludicrous. Has anyone who contributed to the proposals been or met a teenage boy? Of course this will be abused. Unbelievable that it’s being considered. For the safety of the students and the protection of the parent-child relationship these proposals should be abandoned in their entirety.


Follow the science.

Follow the science.  There are two sexes, male and female, as identified by XY and XX chromosomes. Don't confuse helpless children by wielding your power to promote gender dysphoria.  That is child abuse. Each sex deserves their own changing and rest room facilities.  So, don't violate their privacy rights.  That should be a crime. In addition, girls and young women deserve their own sports programs.  They shouldn't have to compete with biological males which puts them at an unfair disadvantage. Finally, do not demand that school employees lie about the sex of anyone.  That is a violation of First Amendment rights, and does a disservice to everyone including the person you want to help. The fact that I have to remind you of these basic truths, should embarrass you.


I support protections for trans students in Virginia!


I support the proposed protections

Anyone citing science hasn't likely looked into the science community's views on gender and needs to start educating themselves before they try to educate others. I am glad to see these proposals to protect our students  in the LGBTQ+ community.


Follow the science.

COL(Ret) Wally Bunyea said what needed to be said most eloquently below.  Unapologetically, I'm not quite so eloquent.  All teachers unions need to be eliminated and many of our school board members need to be fired for pushing their social agendas onto our children of all ages.  This includes our Marxist professors in our American colleges.  STOP THE INDOCTRINATION NOW!  I don't shove my belief systems or heterosexuality down your your throats.  How DARE you think you can do so to OUR children!  They are NOT your children to mold and influence about sexual matters.  Ridiculous how obviously wrong this is.  Leave your personal sexual preferences and agendas where they belong:  In your personal life.  Stop trying SO HARD to convince the world your belief system is "normal" and HAS TO BE everyone's belief system.  Perhaps you need to look inward to see why it's so important you need our impressionable children's/college-aged adults' approval.  Next thing you know, pedophilia will be legalized.  One deviation leads to one more, then one more.  Where does it end?   STOP THE MADNESS NOW!   Parents have finally opened their eyes and WE ARE ONTO YOU!  LEAVE OUR CHILDREN ALONE! Follow the science. Follow the science.  There are two sexes, male and female, as identified by XY and XX chromosomes. Don't confuse helpless children by wielding your power to promote gender dysphoria.  That is child abuse. Each sex deserves their own changing and rest room facilities.  So, don't violate their privacy rights.  That should be a crime. In addition, girls and young women deserve their own sports programs.  They shouldn't have to compete with biological males which puts them at an unfair disadvantage. Finally, do not demand that school employees lie about the sex of anyone.  That is a violation of First Amendment rights, and does a disservice to everyone including the person you want to help. The fact that I have to remind you of these basic truths, should embarrass you.


Strongly Oppose VDOE's Transgender Guidelines As a local pastor, I lead a congregation that overwhelming opposes and stands strongly AGAINST the VDOE transgender policies.  This is an extremely dangerous policy for children, parents, teachers, and for the government, citizenship and our freedoms.  These policies will without question bring emotional and psychological and likely physical harm to many students in the future.  We need courageous leaders with common sense enough to let God’s obvious biological design of male and female be honored in a way that protects girls especially and also boys.  Please oppose this and do not let anything resembling it move forward at all.


In full support

I fully support this guidance. All children should be  educated in an environment that accepts them and is safe for them. It’s also important to me that my own children attend schools that respect diversity and value equity.


Reject these transgender guidelines

Please reject these transgender guidelines 100%


Support

I support this guidance because every student deserves a school environment that is safe and welcoming for everyone.


Transgender

I strongly oppose these rasdical theories that eradicate all distinctions between male and female and indoctrinate our school children and ask that you vote NO on this!


Totally opposed to all

These people are sick and need to treated that way. Stop this insanity. Liberalism is a mental disorder.


I strongly oppose these proposed gender policies

I strongly oppose the proposed gender policies!


Reject

Strongly oppose!


As a parent with public school students, I see so many issues with this policy. Please vote NO!

As a public school parent, I see many issues. You are making other students uncomfortable having to share intimate spaces with other genders. Will my high school student be provided a private place to change if he is uncomfortable in a locker room situation? Will my high school student be provided special accommodations in an overnight trip situation? The rest of us have to forego long traditions of homecoming courts, father-daughter dances, etc. because a person might find it uncomfortable? That is not equitable. Pandering to the desires of a few at the expense of most of the others is not equity. Assemblies against all bullying in all forms no matter what the reason is applauded, but assemblies promoting transgender lifestyle is  a promotion of certain beliefs that may counter the beliefs and religion of many students. It is not the purpose of education. Teaching transgender victories is recent and current politics and should only be taught in a class focusing on current events. It should not be part of regular social studies curriculum.


Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in Virginia’s Public Schools

I am strongly opposed to this whole set of regulations re: transgender in our schools.


Strongly Oppose Transgender Policies

I strongly disagree with schools adopting gender-neutral policies. There are innumerable risks to the safety of other students, and it ignores the natural state in which God has created people. The potential for abuse by teachers toward students who are vulnerable, and by other students, aside from the general affront to the decency of many people's beliefs, is great. This is a political, moral and religious issue that families need to handle in their own way. Children are not wards of the state, and school officials should not be in the position of handling a situation like this, particularly outside of the parent's knowledge. Schools will lose a number of very talented teachers if they are forced to adopt these policies. It puts teachers in too vulnerable of a position should a student change their 'identity' from day to day. Not to mention, this completely ignores a teacher's right to believe what they believe about this issue. We can be free until it destroys other people's beliefs, and the gender at birth is clear. The fact we're debating this as a society shows how far we've gone from logic and reality. How can teachers and other students be forced to adopt policies that will go against their conscience so that the minority are comfortable?  This is outrageous. God has entrusted children to their parents, not the school administrators and not the government.


STRONGLY AGREE

I am in full support of these polices. As a school counselor, it is my ethical duty to make sure ALL students are treated with respect and have equal rights. Students should feel safe and included at school and these polices will help transgender students feel this way.


In Full Support of All Children Being Accepted and Safe

I am in full support of the Virginia Depart of Education’s guidelines. All students deserve to feel safe and accepted while at school (and elsewhere). Having been a former teacher and central office professional development employee, i know this guidance will be helpful to provide consistent guidelines across the state in all school divisions. Thank you for thoughtfully creating these guidelines to protect the future.


this could be easily abused, oppose

I'm worried that my child could be negatively affected by the school or governing body for stating an observation that my child may not have been made aware of.  Why would disciplinary action be taken for a student OR teacher that may honestly not have known there was a 'preferred' pronoun. If it is not made obvious to the student or faculty member, it should not be considered harassment or discrimination as a 'preference' may not be obvious.  The schools already do an extremely poor job at 'stopping' bullying regarding students, maybe that should be worked on before more occurs. This could easily be abused by an individual to use this against another for selfish reasons (bullying) if this is the action that would be taken for a common and obvious assumption that has otherwise not been brought to the "harasser's" attention.


Support

This seems like common sense, trans kids are kids and deserve to be in a supportive environment where they can grow and be safe. I fully support this as it is a step in the right direction. Don't let religious bigots dominate the narrative, we are talking about protecting children in school, all kids deserve to feel safe while in school and this can absolutely help with that.


Wholeheartedly SUPPORT

We ABSOLUTELY need to support this policy, and protect our young trans folx from bullying and harassment.  We need to adopt and foster INCLUSIVITY in all areas of society as well.  I'm also glad to be able to read the opposing comments to this policy so that my family and I can actively AVOID people who have such ignorance, bigotry, and hatred in our community.  Those people should be ashamed of themselves.


Support Trans Youth

I strongly support our trans youth & making them feel safe & accepted at school is a basic, fundamental right. So many of these students are lost to suicide every year because of hateful bullying & lack of acceptance of their true selves. Please vote to support this legislation & to support the trans community.


Guidance Document

FULLY SUPPORT


FULLY SUPPORT

Fully Support


Support our Transgender Community

Our Transgender community needs to be supported. Especially Transgender teens have a much higher rate of suicide, we need this to end. They need to know that their school system has their back and is supportive of them and is doing everything in their power to do these things.


FULLY SUPPORT

I fully support these common sense guidelines for making sure ALL students are safe and welcome at school.


Strongly Support Trans Youth

Bigotry, discrimination, bullying, and transphobia have no place in Virginia schools. This guidance document change simply affords to all students the agency provided all others. Virginia must comply with nondiscrimination laws. All students ARE entitled to a safe and supportive learning environment free from discrimination and harassment for all students. There can be no question that these are fundamental rights of all people. I strongly urge Virginia to adopt the guidance document change and fully embrace non-discriminatory, inclusive, guidance and access to public education for all Virginia students.


Support of transgender student guidelines

I am in full support of the proposed guidance. I have a close friend with a transgender son who homeschools him in order to shield him from discrimination and the pain of non- acceptance. Every child has a right to a good education and the right to live their truth. These students are no different than others with the same hopes and aspirations. Please pass the proposed guidance.


100% Support

I fully support this evidence-based, common sense guidance. EVERY student in the Commonwealth has the right to learn in an environment that is safe, equitable, and inclusive - regardless of gender identity. As an employee of Richmond Public Schools, I have seen firsthand the positive impact that a nurturing school environment can have on the health and well-being of students. LGBTQ+ students, who face bullying and discrimination at higher rates than their cisgender and heterosexual classmates, must be afforded the same opportunities to feel safe and cared for while at school. These model policies are a necessary step in ensuring equity for all students across Virginia.


Oppose proposed Transgender Policies

Gender confusion among school age children is not unknown. Most of these students outgrow their gender/sex confusion and become comfortable with their biological bodies as determined by their DNA.                                                                                Our biological bodies are either boy or girl, man or woman. Confusion over sex and gender are the same thing. Confusion over your sex and gender is a mental problem. You don't solve mental problems with hormones and surgery.                                                                                The proposed Transgender Policies for Virginia schools would open up a Pandora's box of problems. You're acting on a students without any other information. This makes no sense. And it will have students gaming the system.                                                                                The proposed policies completely take the parents out of the picture. They either accept the school's dictates or are told to get lost. What happened to parental authority for children under eighteen years of age? That's a big change in the law.                               Transgenderism, when it exists , should be treated by professionals who have experience in this area. Our children and students must not be sent down a road leading to confusion, high risk, depression and possible suicide. This policy is not in the best interests of our children.                                                                                John Green


Strongly oppose!

We need to keep the distinctions between genders for our children.


100% support

I urge you to completely support these standards to provide basic decency to transgender students.  These are long overdue.   Transgender students have a much higher suicide rate than cisgender students.  All this asks is that we treat them with basic decency.


Fully support

I fully support this common sense guidance because all students are entitled to a safe and non-discriminatory learning environment.


100% support

This is necessary guidance.


INGSOC & Newspeak does not overwrite real definitions of male and female

Male: noun - a person bearing an X & Y chromosome pair in the cell nuclei and normally having a penis, scrotum, and testicles, and developing facial hair; a boy or a man. Female: noun - a person bearing two X chromosomes in the cell nuclei and who has a vagina, uterus, and ovaries, and developing a relatively rounded body and enlarged breasts at puberty, and retaining a hairless face; a girl or woman. There is a war on women by the international left. They seek to turn all sports into sports dominated by men just to start. A man wearing a skirt, a wig, or who has breast transplants is still a man because of his biological makeup, which cannot change no matter how the man “feels” on a given day and irregardless to the level of indoctrination he, and those around him, have been programmed with. Just as a woman will always be a woman no matter how she dresses because chromosomes cannot be changed. Instead of lying to Americans and trying to force them to believe INGSOC and newspeak definitions for well established words, we should be celebrating the differences between men and women. Most women are awesome at being women just as most men are awesome at being men. When we demand that there be no difference between anyone, we eliminate just another part of what being an individual truly means. I pulled my son out of lefty centers of indoctrination (public “schools”) last year as I saw this nonsense coming. Stop indoctrinating the next generation into Orwellian BS. This proposed change is designed to drive a wedge between Americans and it will forever damage the relationship we have with our fellow Americans. ”The (democrat) party seeks power entirely for its own sake. [They] are not interested in the good of others; [they] are interested solely in power, pure power.” ~ George Orwell, 1984.


Support, 100%

Gender fluidity has been present all over the world for as long as human history can show. Gender norms change constantly over time, by region, and religion. These strict human constructs have shown to do harm. Numerous studies show suicides decrease with acceptance, https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=transgender+suicide+decreases&hl=en&as_sdt=0&as_vis=1&oi=scholart


No way

It is about time that we the people of VA fight to support our Christian values with common sense. We have to stop government telling a parent how to parent.  It is about time the people of Virginia stop and stand up for our values and rights. This state is trying to erase everything that we stand for as Christians and citizens of this once fine State of Virginia.


Born a female by God - His decision not mine

Transgender Proposal for VA school systems.

I oppose this current proposal of Transgender policies for VA school systems!!  This will affect all humans and totally goes against our creator GOD!


??SUPPORT??

Transgender individuals, especially young ones, deserve the basic respect of everyone. I believe this piece of legislation is very helpful!


Support

I wholeheartedly support the guidance document for the treatment of trans and gender non-binary students in middle and high school. These young people are at increased risk for being harassed or bullied, and are at increased risk for mental health problems which are not intrinsic to their gender status, but are the result of  bullying by classmates, or worse, by teachers or administrators. Inclusive policies based on current research and understanding of gender issues won't solve all the problems these students encounter--but it's appropriate for a school system to set the tone for how students are treated, and to lead the way in meeting their needs. Schools must be part of the solution, not part of the problem.


Progress in the right direction

I strongly support this piece of legislation. It was thoughtfully crafted. All peoples, particularly those belonging to marginalized groups like the transgender community, deserve respect, understanding, and legal protection of their freedoms. I am proud of this legislation, and I hope to see it implemented with fidelity soon.


Whole heartedly approve

Approve!


I am in FULL SUPPORT

I fully support the implementation of these Model Policies in every school in Virginia. At their root, they are about nondiscrimination -- surely an idea that everyone can get behind. Transgender and gender non-conforming individuals face regular harassment, bullying, and discrimination in workplaces, schools, and public areas, and these policies will go a long way to making sure that every Virginia child has a safe space. To the dissenters, these policies are not the result of random experiences or a specific agenda, they come from the lived and shared experience of 100s and 1000s of transgender folx who experience depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts on a daily basis because of the way they are treated, as well as thorough and non-partisan research conducted by the VDOE, school psychologists, school social workers, and family specialists. It has the support of stakeholders from across Virginia's school systems, professional associations, and individuals who have either the academic expertise or lived experience to conclude definitively that policies like this would help.


Support!

To be ready to learn, kids need to feel safe. These policies will help make schools safe for our LGBTQ kids.


STRONGLY OPPOSE

I strongly oppose the VDOE's proposed guidelines in regards to "transgender" policies!!!


Christy (a native Virginian and resident of VA)

Vehemently disapprove

I do not approve of the proposed guidelines. They are based on radical theories that eradicate all distinctions between male and female and indoctrinate our school children. Virginia is rapidly becoming the laughingstock of the nation.  I don’t want our tax dollars supporting such nonsense.  We are seriously thinking about moving to another state.


Strongly Oppose!

i Strongly Oppose this very much!


Hold teachers and administrators accountable!

Teacher's tenure contracts should hold a clause that if they do harm to any student or demographic that they will be fired, regardless of the protections tenure holds for them. This would include if they have been investigated and found to have expressed any anti-LGBTQ, racist, misogynist, or ableist beliefs to any student or staff. It would go on record and be cause for termination. Any teacher who holds anti-LGBTQ sentiments are a threat to LGBTQ students and create an environment that allows discrimination and harm. Secondary to that they should also be enrolled in the databases police search to conduct background checks for churches, scout organizations, sports organizations, and any other background check conducted on adults who have contact with students so organizations are aware of the threat posed by that person for their LGBTQ children. That information should be provided to these groups requesting background investigations so they can make the determination if the (former) teacher still poses a threat to minors.


Fully support

I fully support the humane and equal treatment of transgender and non-binary students so that they can fully thrive and safely attend VA schools. As long as this bill is encouraging guidelines in support of maintaining safe, encouraging, and empathetic learning environments for transgender and non-binary students* — which I think it is — then I'm fully in support. *Allow transgender and non-binary students to do the following: to live fully within their gender identity; to go by chosen names and pronouns; dress according to their gender identity; fully participate in all school activities, including sports teams that are in line with their gender identity; feel safe because there are programs in place to prevent of anti-transgender/non-binary bullying; etc.


Strongly Oppose Transgender Proposals

These proposals are very unreasonable: gender is determined at birth, and cannot be proven otherwise. If gender is a choice, then it is subjective.  Such permissive policies would lead to (among others): unfair sports competition, sexual abuse caused by elimination of privacy, inappropriate dress, and the challenging of parental authority.


Create a Safety Plan for LGBTQ Students

Clearly, the plethora of negative comments for this indicates the lack of safety for LGBTQ students in schools. Each school should have an active safety plan for each LGBTQ student to address harassment, active shooters, abuse at home, abuse from the community, and abuse from teachers and administrators, to include safety officers assigned just to protect the LGBTQ students from physical and social/emotional assault and harassment. The safety officers would be able to keep and submit records of harassment and assault to the city, county, or state PD, as well as enter the information into CJIS if the offender moves to another state, or moves on to other groups to conduct their anti-LGBTQ harassment.


Strongly disapprove!

I strongly disapprove of these policies. Children under the age of 16 or 18 in particular are not mature enough to drive or vote. How can young children, who don’t even understand what sex is all about, be mature enough to make such a decision.


Create safe zones for LGBTQ students to go to, give representation for them in meetings

LGBTQ students would benefit from having a space similar to a teacher's lounge to go to if they are facing harassment or assault. There should also be an LGBTQ student support association that would advocate for LGBTQ students for any policy changes within schools or administrations.


I fully support the Model Policy.

Everyone means everyone! This is a step to help further bring people together and create a more inclusive culture.


Proposed changes are not strong enough

The language used does not provide enough support for students to actively participate in all levels of the school as a cis-gender, heteronormative student would. Stronger language requiring the changes and sanctions for failing to establish or adhere to the standards of inclusion should be inserted into the proposal.


Oppose

First, I apologize for not having ample time to review this document thoroughly. However, I think my observations and questions are valid. What I find confusing is on page 5 Section 22.1-23.3 - why does the VA code not include athletics? If Trans students are to be treated fairly as Title IX indicates on page 7 - why are VA public schools excluding athletics? Is this to say that Trans students should have all of these considerations put in place, except for when they want to play a sport that is opposite of their physical characteristics? Under the Student Policy/Confidentiality section on page 11 "When a student undergoes public transition...schools need to set clear boundaries about being gender inclusive." How is this to be enacted? How are schools going to control students from making fun of each other/bullying? Are schools going to impose zero tolerance policies for harassment of trans students? If so, how will schools ensure Black and Brown students are not over-represented in discipline and referral actions now that, for example, if a student says something negative about a Trans students - they are now suspended or given detention? It is clear that his policy was not created with the input of parents, as not one is listed on pages 3-4. It is a shame that this policy was not created with the consideration of scholarly work such as The End of Gender: Debunking the Myths about Sex and Identity in our Society by Dr. Debra Soh; Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters by Abigail Shrier; and Ostgathe et al., (2014) found here: https://www.researchgate.net/deref/http%3A%2F%2Fdx.doi.org%2F10.11648%2Fj.ajap.20140306.14 .; and Douglas Murray's The Madness of Crowds: Gender, Race and Identity. There is not conclusive evidence to suggest that Trans students should not be diagnosed with BIID or Gender Dysphoria. This policy goes on to perpetuate the raising of children absent of parental input. Meaning, this policy is usurping parent's rights to be involved in their child or adolescent's life. This is ethically and morally unjust.


transgender policy changes for Loudoun schools

I am tired of paying taxes in order for schools to run their social experiments on children, dividing people, causing confusion and neglecting real education for all of this insane nonsense, not to mention the "teaching" of horrible grammar.  Distracting teachers from their duties, making everyone uncomfortable and leaving no one with any sort of conscientious objections to being used and abused this way.  This is ridiculous


This LGBTQ AGENDA does NOT belong in our schools!

Parents MUST be notified about ANY changes to what is being taught.  Otherwise, pornography, communism, or coven theory could be taught. Attempts to enforce this will be grounds for child abuse lawsuits. The child's or teacher's or parents' morals/ethics are completely disregarded. Boys invading girls' toilets would require suing the principal & school board. [rape, invasion of privacy, etc.] Child can change identities any time: nobody will know WHAT to call it. Children with breasts can go topless in locker rooms & swimming activities.


Why this? Why now?

Why is this a priority item for the education department?  There are so many bigger issues to focus on, specifically education itself.  With over 300 days since our children have been in a physical school building, they are falling behind.  This issue is not a priority and frankly needs to be discussed when we can debate this in person due to the many flaws in your assessment. Parents will not be notified that their child is being interrogated by school officials for allegedly violating these policies, or have the opportunity to intervene on their child’s behalf, UNLESS the complaints are not resolved “at the school level.” Parents wouldn't be notified?  How is it possible that LEGAL GUARDIANS wouldn't be notified about an issue that pertains to their children? If students are allowed to claim to be either a biological male or female (or both, neither, or something else entirely) for any duration of time, without providing any evidence to a teacher or administrator, how do the teacher comply?  How will you keep our children safe?  If a biological male claims to identify as female and has full access to bathrooms and locker rooms, how are you protecting biological females and giving THEM a choice on whether or not they want a boy in their locker room? You are proposing big changes that would negatively impact the majority of your student population for a small group of people.  Why not make individual exceptions for this small minority, rather than force all students, faculty and administrators to comply with an empirically debatable view of sex and gender, especially if it directly conflicts with their own fundamental beliefs.


STOP CONFUSING OUR CHILDREN-- TOTALLY DISAPPROVE TO THIS PROPOSAL!!!!

Who we want or decide to be from minute to minute CANNOT change what GOD created us to be, we have to remember that we are creatures not "The Creator"! Please do not confuse our children and spread more errors -- this is why there is so much chaos and strife in the world, government leaders keep injecting false and erroneous policies.  The government does not have authority over GOD's authority! Gen. 1:27 "God created man in HIS own image, in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them."  There is nothing in between. Please meditate on this.


Not the truth

this is not the truth. This leads to a dark future


Please wake up

This is just insane.


Protect parental rights and religious freedom in the counseling of children

No, I strongly oppose this bill. Stop wasting time with all of the nonsense bills. The needed bill is to bring God back to our children maybe we will have less suicide.


Opposed - Don't disregard role of parents

The proposed policies articulate views – such as the view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” – that are far different from those of many parents. Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has gone far beyond the path the General Assembly prescribed. Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


Strongly oppose

I strongly oppose the VDOEs proposed guidelines in regards with transgender policies.


I am against the Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in Virginia's Public Schools for the following reasons: Failure to use a student's new "preferred pronouns" - which can change from day to day and even defy basic rules of grammar ("ze/hir/hirs", "they/them/their")- would be "harassment" and "discrimination", for which both faculty and students would be subject to disciplinary action. Schools will be permitted to help a student explore, facilitate and make decisions regarding their gender expression of sexual identity while at school, without a parent even knowing! Parents who encourage their children to embrace their God-given sex would be at risk of being reported for child abuse or neglect by the school. Schools would be prohibited from notifying parents if a biological male is using the same changing facility as their daughter that was designated for girls. All students will be allowed to use any bathroom or locker room they choose, without being questioned by any school administrator or faculty, eliminating privacy and safety of students in states of undress. The requirements for schools to maintain gender-neutral dress code standards will cause disruptions and distractions, permitting boys to wear skirts and girls to go topless in activities where boy can- such as swimming or teams. Parents will not be notified that their child is being interrogated by school officials for allegedly violating these polices, or have the opportunity to intervene on their child's behalf. UNLESS the complaints are not resolved "at the school level." The policies provide absolutely no exceptions or accommodations for a student or teacher whose religious faith, conscience, or understanding of biology and sociology prevents them from being able to go along with the "transgender" ideology and policies. There are many more reasons to oppose the proposed Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in Virginia's Public Schools.  These policies are detrimental to our educational system and will only add more problems then what they hope to solve. Please do not support these policies!


Oppose this Strongly

If passed this will undercut parental rights to raise their children.  How can we say that there are more than two sexes?  You are born male or female.  If a person eventually chooses to associate with the sex opposite of what they were born as, so be it, but do not place those non-science based beliefs on others via law.


No child

No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex.


Strongly oppose

By taking an affirming stance towards gender transition, you are limiting teachers and counselors in doing their job of holistically assessing a student and his or her needs (and entirely negating parental rights).  There is no other psychological condition in which a diagnosis precedes an evaluation.  I encourage you to read “Irreversible,” which discusses the long term damage of hasty affirming diagnosis. Sadly, the children who have been hastily “guided” through transitions they later regret as adults are the victims of this misguided and scientifically ignorant movement.


Strongly oppose--protect parental rights and child safety and religious freedom

Strongly oppose. Please protect child safety, parental rights, and religious freedom.


Oppose

I oppose this document. It is based on the falsehood that people have a sex "assigned at birth" but which can subsequently change.


No transgender teachings at all!

You are disregarding parents when you make decisions. PARENTS ARE THE ULTIMATE AUTHORITY!


gender issues

The proposed policies articulate views – such as the view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six” – that are far different from those of many parents. Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has gone far beyond the path the General Assembly prescribed. Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


Oppose

Don't make young children uncomfortable by forcing them to share bathrooms and other facilities with the opposite sex. The rights and privacy of each individual should be respected.


Oppose

Child's brain not developed to make such judgments. Gender dysphoria is temporary. Parents, Doctors, and Psychologists need to be involved.  Oppose.


Opposed

Stop confusing the  children. Strongly opposed.


Transgender Policies

The proposed policies show the extent to which policy-makers have lost their common sense.  Don't the policy-makers realize that transgendered individuals are much more prone to mental illness and premature death than the non-transgendered population?  (Cf. https://soundsliketransedu.com/uncategorized/suicide-stats-in-trans-comm/ ) Why do you want to encourage children to pursue a path that leads to mental illness and premature death?  That is not a rhetorical question! The proposed policies articulate views – such as the view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” – that are far different from those of many parents. Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has gone far beyond the path the General Assembly prescribed. Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


Virginia DOE Transgender proposed policy

Some good ideas especially on bullying but some very poorly thought out ideas on students expected to share bathrooms and showers with members of the opposite sex. If kids are really confused as to what bathroom or shower they should use, build them new ones and as a taxpayer I will gladly pay the increase in my taxes.  All the requirements under this proposed policy will likely cost more than just modifying your facilities.  Your trying to fix a problem by creating a bigger one that abdicates your responsibility to your students.  What about the rights of students and their families who are very opposed to these radical ideas that seems to be written more to address the needs of the adult authors than the student population ! You are driving people out of your schools instead of solving a problem.  Good luck with this poorly thought out plan.


Strongly Support

These policies are absolutely crucial for transgender students.  We must do what we can to support the social and emotional wellbeing of all students, regardless of their gender identity.  These are excellent policies that respond to real issues impacting transgender youth's accessibility to learning.


Strongly Support Transgender Student Policies

Thank you for codifying rights and protections for our most vulnerable students and not allowing ignorant or hateful voices to derail these protections. My child suffered immensely due to lack of understanding in public school. Please stand up and do the right thing by all our children and protect the rights of our transgender students.


Strongly support!!!!!!

this is extremely important for lgbtqia+ youth. They deserve to feel welcomed, supported, seen, and heard. Religious or personal interests groups ideals and opinions should have no influence over public education and over the lives of children attending those public institutions. Every child deserves an education where they are safe and protected.


Mind your business

these children just want to be accepted for who they are, imagine how much this could help that! This could also teach our kids to accept differences at such a young age, strongly support!!!


Strongly Oppose!

Do not pass this!


SUPPORT EVERYONE

I’m in favor of this being passed. There’s absolutely no reason trans folk of ANY age need to discriminated against, ESPECIALLY at school!! Don’t be hateful and nasty. If you don’t want you children around people of all walks of life, go to a new school. Your hate is unwelcome here.


Strongly Oppose

Allow parents to make decisions about the worldview and values with which they raise their own children.


FULLY SUPPORT!

I fully support this!


Complete Support

The comments of opposition are absolutely sickening and disheartening. A school should be a safe and supportive environment of every single student within it, regardless of gender, sexual orientation, race, and religion. Transgender students 110% deserve these rights and protections just as much as any other student. No child should be discriminated against, and every child in a school deserves to be protected. It does not matter what your opinion is, take you child to a private religious school if it bothers you so, but religion is left out of public schools for a reason and they shall not cater to your bigoted and outdated belief systems.


support for transgender students

I Fully support all transgender and binary students in Virginia schools. Don't allow these wonderful students to have to hide as I had to back in the 60's and 70's. It is tough enough to deal with the peer pressure they have to endure but having the state make them hide their true identity is inhumane and so destructive to their health and well being.


Support for Model Policies for the Treatment for Transgender Students

I strongly support inclusion regardless of sexual orientation and identity.  Please implement the model policies for the treatment of transgender students in Virginia's public schools.  All students should be treated with dignity and respect, and the model policies are a critical step toward that goal.


Fully in support!!

Fully in support!


em

em


Strongly support!!!

I strongly support this!!! Youth are already subject to so much hate for trying to be themselves, and LGBTQIA+ deserve to feel SAFE, loved, respected, and heard by their community. We create productive members of society but nurturing them and giving them a healthy chance, not by hating and pushing certain groups aside because of the ridiculous notion that they don't deserve the same respect.


Policies for the treatment of transgender students

I do not agree with the proposed guidelines regarding transgender students.  I have long been a proponent of various types of civil rights and strongly believe all people and all segments of our society should be equally respected and cared for.  Being caring and respectful of transgender students does not mean that we need to go overboard in our eagerness to make sure they feel included and respected.  These guidelines go way overboard and do not make common sense.  Also, it is important for the parents of students under 18 years of age not be to blocked from what is happening in their child's school or classroom.


I support this change. Thank you to those grueling to make schools a better, safer place.


I Fully support!

I fully support


Fully support!

I fully support this positive change. No one should be discriminated against based on their gender identity, sexual orientation, race or ethnicity.


Fully support!!

Fully support!!


support!!

School is supposed to act as a safe space for students to learn and grow. This should be the case for all students, including those of the LGBTQ+ community.


SUPPORT

STRONGLY SUPPORT


Fully, emphatically support

thank you for recognizing the value in affirming every child


Fully Support Transrights!

Everyone one should have the same rights, regardless of gender.


Protect Trans Youth (and all trans people)

Trans youth are extremely vulnerable members of our society and need as much protection and support as possible. Protection and safety within the schools are the most key factor. I fully and 100% give my support to this proposal and believe these policies will increase the livelihood of many people. The oppression in hate in these comments are the minority when you look at the bigger picture of the world and are downright disgusting. Trans people must be protected and be given full and equal support.


i fully support this as a student!!

i’m currently a sophomore in high school, and i 10000% support this. by doing this, trans kids will be much more comfortable at school than they are right now. as a friend of several transgender and non-binary students, i want them to be the most comfortable and accepted at school as they can be. the fact that these policies don’t already exist in 2021 is just unfair and disgusting. many people have been commenting about how it’s “weird” and “against science,” which is completely untrue. there is a big difference between SEX and GENDER. sex is female, male, and intersex. gender is a social construct. these people believing that there’s only two genders need to go back to biology class. everyone who is opposing these policies are transphobic scum of the earth who need to stop being ignorant and actually learn to be a decent human being. many people opposing this policy have also been writing their name in as “anonymous,” and it just shows how cowardly they are. these people have also been commenting on how “this will confuse kids,” but these policies would in fact normalize it, and help them better understand transgender people. i have never once felt uncomfortable around someone who’s transgender or gender non-conforming, so i’d have absolutely 0 issue with a transgender girl using the same bathroom as me, and i fully support all of these policies.


I FULLY SUPPORT!!

I fully support trans students


Fully Support

Fully Support


Fully support

Protect and support all trans people


I support!

I support


Fully Support.

This proposal would be an incredible step forward for the protection of transgender students. School is a fundamental part of every young person’s life, and every student deserves to feel accepted and embraced there. The transgender community is very vulnerable to harassment and bullying, so helping the youngest members is an important and urgent cause. I offer my full support.


I 100% support this.

Everyone deserves to feel protected, especially in a learning environment. There should be no questions or debates about this, regardless of someone’s personal hatred towards a group of people. Seeing as many object to this, these people definitely need to be protected from those close minded around them.


it’s an illness b

down with the sickness


Strongly Support

As the parent of two wonderful LGBTQ+ children, I fully support this document. We need written guidelines to ensure that all students are affirmed, respected, and able to learn safely in schools. Thank you!


Strongly Support

There's no such thing as a transgender student, only a student who is transgender. Gender identity has nothing to do with being a student therefore should not impact one's right to learn in a safe learning environment. Virginia schools are already falling behind other states with more inclusive policies. Protecting students is not "radical" it's a basic expectation.


Full support

As the parent of two Virginia public school students (one he, one she), I fully support this proposal to move towards are more inclusive, supportive environment for all.  We can make a difference, and this is a step in the right direction.


Strongly Support.

Trans rights are human rights. I strongly support these guidelines.


I Support

I full support the protection of trans students.


I support! :)

I support! :)


These policies should not be adopted

Schools should not adopt these or any transgender policies.  Schools should not be able to help students explore or make decisions about their gender identity.  It is up to the parent or guardian to make decisions concerning their minor children.   Students should not get to pick which bathroom or locker room they go into.  I would not want my daughter to be made to change in a locker room with males present or use a restroom where males could also be present.  This is a big safety concern.  Religious freedoms will be violated if parents are told they cannot discuss God with their minor children in relation to their biological sex.  This topic is best left at home; it is not for the schools to teach.


Strongly oppose.

schools should focus on academics and let parents focus on social issues.


Christine Jones, Virginia State Co-Leader, Free Mom Hugs

Dignity for all and equity under the law starts with education - I support wholeheartedly!

I have seen the mental and emotional toll of inequities and cruelties in our schools against transgender students.  You have only to look at statistics from The Trevor Project to begin to understand the seriousness of this issue.  Almost 1 in 2 transgender youths have considered suicide.  This discrimination can only be ended with education.  Thank you for finally addressing this issue.


PROTECT TRANS YOUTH

I absolutely support this!! TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS!!


In full support of this.

To people who are disagreeing please put yourself in someone else’s shoes for once.


STRONGLY OPPOSE

I STRONGLY OPPOSE the Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in Virginia’s Public Schools. These policies exclude the parents from their proper role in the lives of their children, deliberately disrupting the nuclear family. Parents have the primary responsibility for the upbringing and welfare of their children. The proposed policy would violate the rights of parents and prevent them from properly fulfilling their God-given responsibilities. I urge the Virginia Department of Education to use good judgement and common sense and drop the proposed transgender policies.


Transgender Bill

Trans rights are human rights. Please implement this policy to help protect all children. Let’s teach children that kindness to all people is important


I support!

I believe that schools should create safe spaces for students in general. This definitely applies to those who find school unsafe or where they may have the opportunity to be treated unequally.


Support Trans Youth

Virginia Department of Education's best practices outline meaningful ways to create more inclusive school environments for trans students. This draft guidance should receive full support and implementation.


Transgender laws

Strongly oppose!!


This teacher strongly supports

Every child deserves to be treated equally.  They have a right to be educated no matter what their race, economic status, gender, or life choices are.  Having taught a primary grade for more than 20 years, I have seen and learned that students are born the way they are born.  We need to love, support, and educate them as we do with all our students.


Fully support!

This needs to happen for their emotional and mental well-being. Definitely a yes from me. It does so much more harm to deny or ignore this.


Our children

All students need and deserve our support.


choose to show love and not hate— protect trans rights

It’s a simple choice we are presented with daily— to conduct a life of love or hate. Protect trans rights, notice those who need support.


oppose

Chromosomes are assigned at birth by God. If we act on our feelings regardless of the truth, the result can be disastrous. These kinds of laws along with the encouragement of the LGBQT movement from such a young age, steals a child's innocence. It contributes to confusion, depression, and suicide. I oppose this legislation.


I STRONGLY SUPPORT TRANS YOUTH!

I support the LGBTQ+ community, trans youth are already going through a lot by coming out as trans we need to support them throughout their journey to living their truth. The gender these individuals identify as is not anyone’s concern. If opposing individuals have so much hate towards the trans community they need to reconsider their values and beliefs.


FULLY SUPPORT AND STRONGLY ENDORSE!

The protection of our youth regardless of race, gender, sexuality etc... should be our top priority in education and reality. We need to protect them especially in an educational environment even if students/faculty do not understand them. Bullying and discrimination of youth regarding their identity is completely inexcusable no matter the environment but especially in schools. Our students should not have to worry about their safety at school. Those opposing this are ignorant of acceptance and equality of all. “The lack of these basic rights is what leads to long-term, irreparable inequity in adulthood and should be avoided at all costs through the upmost protection of youth via protective and inclusive policy,” (Téa Le). Think about if you had a child... would you want them to be discriminated against and bullied due to their own identity?


Disagree with transgender education

I do not want to see transgender education come to Loudon county. As a mom of elementary school students, I think it is totally inappropriate for children that have no interest in the topic of sexuality. I do not want my child’s educators telling them that a person can change their gender, and believe that will only create confusion. Furthermore, it is wrong for an educational system to impose their moral beliefs on countless families of faith who do not share those beliefs. I support anti-bullying/kindness training, and this should be more than enough to support a transgender student, without forcing innocent students into premature discussions on sexuality for the sake of a small minority.


Teacher in FULL Support

I am a middle school teacher and I am in FULL support of these guidelines. Over the past few years, I have had multiple students who identify as transgender or nonbinary, or who are beginning to explore their gender identity. Overall, their peers have been understanding and supportive. The kids get it--it's about time policy caught up! Having these guidelines will be great to help shift unintentionally discriminatory wordings (such as concert dress codes) as well as build a future that is inclusive of our non-binary students (such as designing new buildings with plans for single-use bathrooms). It will also help educate teachers who are not as aware or informed about how to navigate having a non-binary student. Our goal should always be to create a safe and welcoming environment for ALL of our students, and this is a huge step in the right direction.


If you are a parent or teacher please read and SUPPORT this policy

I fully support this policy. We must protect our trans youth in a time where they are most vulnerable while  providing them with our support and safety. Please rethink if it were to be your child and the support, guidance, and love that they would need from you.  If you do not support or agree maybe homeschooling or private school may be a better option for your child. Religion is kept out of PUBLIC schools and should never be an excuse, you’re only spreading hate. If you are a parent and do not support this I am scared for your child’s future and the wrong, hateful ideas you put into their heads. If you are a teacher and do not support this policy you should reconsider your career because the only job you have is to educate and support children, never discriminate. The importance of safety for all kids should never be a debate.


I support

I support!!


FULLY SUPPORT!!!!

Fully support this move!!! Protect all trans youth!!!!


FULLY SUPPORT

There is absolutely NO reason to not support this. Our education systems NEED to change along with our world and society or we will forever be failing our youth and regressing.


Basic Human Rights! Protect trans kids!

Access to equitable and identify agreeing resources are a basic right to all youth. Trans rights are human rights.


I SUPPORT

I SUPPORT! no one should be discriminated for their identity!!!


Strongly oppose

No doubt our children are facing many decisions and challenges. I fully support adults  coming alongside to offer wisdom and support, but I cannot support these purposed policies. I am an educator and mother. Evidence is overwhelming to show the need for boundaries and rules for children. When we give children the ability to choose anything they want with no correct or incorrect they become lost. Children questioning gender identity need support, however, I am very concerned that instituting policies such as these will only cause more children to question something they never would have considered before.


i support.

I FULLY SUPPORT THIS!


SUPPORTING 100%

Happy to support!


Support our trans kids!!

Support our trans kids!


SUPPORT!!

We HAVE to support and protect LGBTQ+ children.


Fully Support: Protect Trans Children

There’s absolutely no reason not to fully support this. Trans children should feel safe and comfortable while receiving their education as well. The lack of accommodation school systems make for students in the LGBTQ+ community significantly puts them at a higher risk. We should be doing the upmost to make sure all kids are not only safe and comfortable but getting the education they deserve.


I support

I support


JC, former parent with kids in public schools in VA

Oppose New Gender Policy from both Natural and practical reasons.

At what point does it end?  Depending on if you are in Europe or in the US, the number of these "identities" varies greatly.  I understand that one site in Europe lists 71 such identities, and does not give you the option of male and female.  If you do press forward with this, I strongly argue that EVERY IDENTITY be give their own restroom.  That way NO ONE would be forced into a restroom with an IDENTITY that they do not want to be with. Additional issues include 300% higher suicide rate than two gender kids.  This rate does not decrease even in the most permissive and accepting situations. From natural standpoint, our species is two-gendered.  While there is an occasional, genetic anomaly, the actual occurrence is not sufficiently large that would justify this extensive and self-declarative policy where anyone could make up whatever they or a parent wants.  I would strongly argue that sexuality is a learned response pushed by our media.  A media that glamorizes the different for shock value.


Fully support!

I fully support this.


Policies for treatment of transgender students

STRONGLY OPPOSE!


I SUPPORT!

I support!!


PROTECT TRANS KIDS

Everyone opposing this is concerned about schools “taking over the parental role”... if you want everything your kids are taught to be streamlined through you, homeschool your kids. Newsflash: respecting transgender rights in school won’t ruin your precious kids, it’ll only make them more tolerant and respectful of others. To any transgender kids/adults reading this: you are valid, valued, and loved.


In full support of trans children

We are in a time where we have two options: have some adults feel somewhat uncomfortable or have children committing suicide. The suicide rate for trans kids without support is heartbreakingly high. It plummets when we treat them with respect and dignity. I'm going to take the option that doesn't result in dead children.


Strongly oppose! I do not agree with the proposed guidelines for transgender students. What is proposed is not something initiated by or promoted by our children. Rather it is part of the agenda of the radical left that wants to take parental control away from where it naturally belongs. Radical theories that eradicate all distinctions between male and female and indoctrinate our school children have no appropriate basis in our culture.


Absolutely fully support!!

Students need to know that they are not only safe, but also accepted and supported in school environments! Personal beliefs held by staff/peers must be disregarded, considering that there is present harm towards a community of students. Think about how this would affect not only the young trans community, but the entire community of LGBTQIA+ youth in our education system!!!


FULLY SUPPORT

FULLY SUPPORT


I fully support

happy to support this brilliant cause!


Strongly Opposed

These policies have gone too far. The school system cannot take the place of the family in these serious matters. I left the teaching profession halfway through my career because of the radical policies that damaged students and attempted to force teachers to support the one narrative that is tolerated by our culture today. Enough is enough.


i support!!!

i support!!!


Trans rights are human rights, fully support.


I fully support!

Happy to support this!


I support Trans and LGBTQIA+ Rights.

I support LGBT+ Rights fully and people who are transgender deserve the same rights as cisgendered people. Make trans people feel comfortable in our state please.


I SUPPORT

I strongly support


Fully support!

i fully support! Trans youth must be protected and there needs to be more measures in place to ensure that.


Opposing the Public Schools Approach to Transgender Students

God made Man (Male) and Woman (Female).  There is no other gender no matter what someone may think or feel. It is very unloving to lead our children into a very dangerous life where they think they can change what they were born as.  In most cases the child will grow out of their need to be the other gender. Please watch "In His Image" that very lovingly shows how persons have lived as another gender and changed back.  We need to be giving these children help to accept their gender and thrive the way God meant it to be for them. I am very opposed to the radical agenda that Virginia has proposed for our Public School Students in regards to Transgender Rights.


I support securing the natural, inalienable rights of lqbtqia+ students.

LQBTQIA+ students deserve the same rights as cis-gender, heterosexual students.


Transgender Policies

I oppose transgender policies that, in particular, limit or exclude parents' rights to educate and mange their children's live in these matters.  No child or teen should be subjected to using bathrooms, dressing rooms, etc. with others of the opposite biological sex.  The primary responsibility of handling these situations needs to be left to parents.  Thank you for the opportunity to voice my opinion. Sincerely, Joan Anderson


I support.

I support.


strongly oppose

These proposed radical policies go far beyond the path prescribed by the General Assembly. The views articulated are harmful and contrary to the experience and views of most parents. For example, that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” is controversial.  And even more terrifying is the view that schools should be advocating for the (in many cases) IRREVERSIBLE "gender transitions" in young children. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. And finally, schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students so no child should be FORCED to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations.


I fully support this

I fully support!!!!


Strongly oppose

strongly oppose


I Fully Support!

Is there any way the Virginia Department of Education can accomplish any of their goals if they aren’t protecting and supporting ALL students? Just the fact that this is even up for debate is sickening. SUPPORT LGBT STUDENTS!


What ever happened to science??

I keep wondering what ever happened to science. Anyone who has studied basic biology knows that humans are either male or female at birth, and that does not change, no matter how you feel about it. These policies are based on lies, subvert parental authority, and are harmful to ALL children.


I wholeheartedly support

I absolutely agree with helping the students in our community feel safe and supported.


I do not support.

I do not support.


Fully Support!

As a person who has worked in education for over ten years, I strongly support clear and compassionate directives for transgender and non-binary students. Every school system in the Commonwealth should require professional development for staff members regarding the lgbtq+ community. From what I’ve witnessed, the children have mostly grown to accept their peers’ identity, it is the staff members (including teachers and counseling staff) that often do the most harm due to a lack of knowledge and understanding. We need clear guidance. Trans/non-binary students not only face harassment & discrimination at a much higher level than their cis peers, they also face increasingly high rates of suicide and self-harm. For many, the school is their only opportunity for a safe haven. Please move forward on state-wide clear directives for this population that so desperately needs our support. Thank you.


First Amendment Rights of Parents

The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children!


oppose; do not disregard the role of parents in public education


Transgender policy

Good bye public schools.


Parents cannot be ignored wrt to transgender issues

Transgender policies like those suggested are damaging to our vulnerable youth especially when implemented without regard to the parents. The view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” is not based on any scientific study and contradicts the experience of anyone who was ever five or six.


Oppose

I strongly oppose these measures. Let's come up with some better solutions so that all parties are respected and feel safe.


opposed

I can understand for the sake of freedom allowing a gender confused child or parent wanting to segregate from their biological identical members, but to force them upon members of the opposite biological sex is imprudent, immoral and criminally dangerous. If you insist on perpetuating this confusion ideology then find another solution even if it is an "other" bathroom or locker room for all the confused.


Object to gender policies in schools

It is bad enough that the true professional mental health experts are not allowed to give true guidence to people who are confused, now we want to encourage kids who are seeing things in the media and on TV that what they are feeling at their current age that they are one of how many genders?  When I was growing up there were two - male and female - that has not changed, by pushing this in the manner that they are doing so, they are confusing kids, taking the power away from the parents and giving it to the state.  No way should a young person walk into their restroom/lockerroom and find a person of the opposite sex there.  You are asking for trouble!  This is something that they should be encouraged to wait until they are in their 20's and fully grown.  Science tells us that their brains are not fully developed until around age 25, not 5! Enough!


Transgender Policies - Opposed

The proposed policies articulate views – such as the view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” – that are far different from those of many parents. Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has gone far beyond the path the General Assembly prescribed. Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


Oppose these regulations. Parents have authority over their children, not schools

I am opposed to having schools decide for my children what is best, this is the first point. Parents should have ultimate authority over their children, knowledge of what happens in schools, knowledge of what their children 'declare' in school, knowledge about birth control and/or abortions and transgender medicines, surgeries , etc. that are sponsored, suggested or offered through schools. If the Virginia Dept of Education really looks at the scientific (non-woke) literature, child suffer immense crisis of identity when they become 'transgender', suicide rates increase, life long damage is done in many many cases. These kinds of policies should NOT be pushed in our VA schools, nor shoved down their - or our- the parents- throats. Why is this being done? To protect the incredibly small number of students who declare themselves as transgender, some not even knowing what it means? In doing so, you, the school system is ignoring and NOT protecting the majority of students. Where are their rights? Trends across the country signal their voice is ignored, dismissed or worse criticized for not being 'in trend' (or woke- enough), in with the times, in step - with what- the minority? Individualism is lost. There will be no freedom to be individual, because these policies will translate into " you must agree with transgenderism, you must not make fun of, you must condone." Religious freedom to speak out or even to voice one's opinion - I am a Christian or Jew or Muslim and I believe there are two genders -a man is man and woman a woman , will be persecuted. We are already seeing this in a number of places. Why would Virginia, my lovely Commonwealth choose such destructive paths? Please listen to the people, the parents. Please do not enact these transgender policies. They are and will be extremely destructive for families and for our children and for the rights of parents to be the authority for their children. Respectfully, M Morris


DO NOT SUPPORT ON ANY LEVEL

PARENTS are the ones who should be teaching anything about human sexuality to their children. This effort to undermine parents and indoctrinate children in schools is abhorrent to any person who believes that gender is not AND NEVER WILL BE "FLUID."  The insane idea that children as young as 5 or 6 can decide to "change" their gender is a form of child abuse that will cause mental and emotional problems for the rest of their lives.  This would also create unsafe environments to allow so-called "transgender" children to share the same locker rooms, play in the same sports teams with children who do not share this mindset.


Parents must have the right to decide

Parents have the right know and to have a say in what their children are taught and the responsibility to raise them in the truth. It is outrageous that schools are teaching such controversial and scientifically unsupportable positions against the wishes of the parents. The decision to teach our children about most fundamental truths of the human must not be controlled by a committee with such an agenda. Parents want what is truly best for their children.


Preserve Our Parental Rights to Monitor and Guide Our Children's Education

Parents are the primary guides of young children and their guidance must not be subverted by the current "vogue" of the sickness of transgender-ism.


Transgender Regulations by VA Dept of Education Are An Illegal Intrusion Into Every Child's Identity

No school system has a right to impose regulations which violate any child's privacy or sense of self-worth nor do they have the right to require that any child of one biological sex be required to permit anyone, adult or child, to view or share with them any state of undress.  Furthermore, it is up to the decision of every child to formulate his/her own sexual identity at whatever stage in his/her physical development they choose to decide "who" or "what" they are physically and mentally.  No governmental organization has the right to intrude in/on that process.  The proposed VDE regulations are therefore an illegal intrusion on a child's privacy and self identity.


Virginia Dept. of Education transgender policies

OPPOSED: I am opposed to the Virginia Department of Education or the Virginia Legislature making any policy advocating or attempting to describe or promote transgender education of any kind.  This is the responsibility of parents, grandparents, or other family members to decide what their children need to know about this topic. Counselors or other government employed individuals are not proper channels for introducing this subject to children of any age.


Parents must have the right to decide !

Parents must have the right to decide !


Transgender Education.

I am opposed to having this subject part of the curriculum. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. VDOE should not disregard the role of parents in public education. Thank you! Leo J. Titus Sr.


Support

Children need emotional support from people in their lives and this guidance is necessary because educating teachers and administrators on how to help kids with questions as well as support children that are not heteronormative is vital. Not doing so will likely exacerbate painful and destructive experiences for everyone at the schools.


Fully support

I fully support the humane and equal treatment of transgender and non-binary students so that they can fully thrive and safely attend VA schools. As I understand this bill it encourages guidelines in support of maintaining safe, and empathetic learning environments for transgender and non-binary students. As a child I was made fun of because other kids thought I was homosexual which I am not. I was very confusing for me and hurt deeply. We need to teach our children to be more unederstanding. Transgender and non-binary students should be able: to live fully within their gender identity; to go by chosen names and pronouns; dress according to their gender identity; fully participate in all school activities, including sports teams that are in line with their gender identity; feel safe because there are programs in place to prevent any anti-transgender/non-binary bullying; etc.


Forced Transgender Policies

Sirs and Madams: It is unthinkable that you would consider allowing biological males into the locker rooms and bathrooms of biological females. Not only is this an unwarranted intrusion into the most private areas of a woman's life, it is pandering to an extrememly small minority of people who are deeply confused and in need of psychological help. More people are coming forward every month to state that surgical mutilation of their bodies did not take care of the deep psychological problems which caused them to think they were females "trapped in a male body." Recently a woman in France sued the doctors who cut off her breasts as part of her "transition to a male." She has come to realize that at the age of sixteen, when this horrible mutilation was done to her, that she was not emotionally mature or stable enough to make such a decision.  She needed counseling, not mutilation. I strongly urge you to do the right thing and resist the emotional wailings of those who are neither scientific in their approach to life nor concerned with the damage that pandering to the idea of transgenderism as a reality will do to young people not mature enough to understand what they are doing. This entire scheme is being pushed by a lobby of homosexuals and other persons who are trying to normalize that which can never be considered normal.


VDOE has gone far beyond the path prescribed by General Assembly--strongly oppose

The proposed policies give a blanket endorsement to such controversial and disputed views as "Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by ages 5 to 6".  A view far different from that of many parents. Schools should not be accommodating that or the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible, "gender transitions". These proposed regulations infringe the First Amendment Rights of parents to raise and care for their children, and would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


This policy should not be imposed on the classroom teacher or applied in the school setting. Teachers have more than enough to worry about without implementing this craziness. This is a personal family matter one in which a child and the parents should have counseling. You should not disregard the role of parents in public education. Regards, Susan Thornton


SUPPORT

sUPPORT


Model policies disregard role of parents

The VDOE should not disregard the role of parents in public education.


Opposed

Opposed


Totally opposed to this lie

ALCON: Genderism is an ideology, not a science. Its premises and conclusions are false. Applying this ideology will result in the distortion of human nature and the misinterpretation of the true, valid needs of Virginia's citizens. There are only two sexes: male and female. I oppose our state jumping into this bandwagon of lies. Best regards, ~P.


Parents are in charge of the children, NOT THE STATE! More reason to homeschool!

No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Parents should be in charge of the children NOT THE STATE!!!


Transgender policy’s

Please don’t disregard the parents role in public schools. Children should not be exposed to such ideals as transgender beliefs. It could endanger the bodily privacy and safety of all students. As a parent this deeply troubles me that the public schools system would do this.


Opposed to Transgender Ideology

All students must be treated with compassion and respect but the implementation of transgender ideology in the school system is odious, mendacious, and harmful to other students. Transgender ideology is riddled with scientific lies, logical fallacies, and harmful consequences; it has no place in the education of our children. It is shameful that the Virginia General Assembly and Governor passed this harmful legislation and worse that the VDOE will mandate its implementation. I firmly and strongly oppose the imposition of this ideology on the children of Virginia.


I support protecting trans students

These kids are vulnerable. Please help to make them safer at school, and to allow them the same rights to participate as other students.


Oppose transgender policies proposed by the Virginia Department of Education

The proposed policies articulate views – such as the view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” – that are far different from those of many parents. Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has gone far beyond the path the General Assembly prescribed. Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


I OPPOSE THIS PROPOSAL

CAN'T WE JUST HAVE COMMEN SENSE AND JUST GET ALONG.


VDOE should not disregard the role of parents in public education.


I OPPOSE THIS

This proposal endangers all students, regardless of what they identify as!


Strongly Oppose

I strongly oppose the VDOE's approval of the draft policies for the treatment of transgender students in public elementary and secondary schools.  These policies undercut parents' involvement in the life of their own children at school, and endanger the bodily privacy and safety of all students.  These policies articulate views that are so far removed from the views of most parents in the Commonwealth of Virginia (and the country), and would only serve to create more confusion in the minds of our children who are constantly bombarded by outside forces seeking to divide the family.  Furthermore, no child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or any other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex.


NO-This is Parent's Domain    Transgender Inst.   Guidance Survey  Va. Town Hall

NO-This is Parent's Domain


I oppose this action.  Parents should be informed.

I oppose this action; parents should be informed.


transgender policy

I am opposed to the proposed transgender policy. Parent view needs to be honored.


Transgender policies

I have 5 grandchildren in the Fairfax County, VA Public Schools. I vehemently oppose the  proposed  transgender  "policies" proposed by the Virginia Department of Education.  They  are another attempt to impose a political minority's views on the majority. .  These policies endanger the privacy and safety of all children.  As a parent of three, children as well, my experience and conventional wisdom belies the assumption that children have fixed gender identity by age 6.  No child should be forced to share a locker room, hotel room, or shower with a person of the opposite biological sex. Parents are the ultimate authority when i comes to raising their children.  No forced imperatives or practices regarding gender politics should prevail.


Guidance Document (Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in VA Public School)

Oppose because only Parents have the right TO DECIDE. NOT STATE OR SCHOOL


This bill is a danger to children, physically, mentally and emotionally

Views such as “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six ” – are contrary to reason and nature, let alone common sense! Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has lost all sense of reality. Schools have a duty to protect the safety of all students as well as their bodily privacy and dignity. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel extremely uncomfortable and possibly even scared when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be encouraging the incredibly harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”, especially since the vast majority of children who don’t transition grow out of these feelings and no longer want to as older teens or adults. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children, and on the rights of children to be protected by adults in authority. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


I oppose.  The role of parents in  public education should not be disregarded.


oppose mixed-gender toilet/shower/changing facilities in schools

All children should be welcomed, valued, and safe in our schools.  Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students.  No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, and the like with a member of the opposite biological sex.  Many children can experience long-lasting, traumatic reactions to this situation. Private (one-person-at-a-time), unisex facilities are acceptable.


I Oppose This Legislation

Sex is innate and biological.  Extreme outliers should not force legislation on the majority.  This legislation will lead to unquestionable child abuse and violation of privacy.  This is a travesty and a predator's dream.  No sane person wants this.


Opposed

I am opposed to this breach of parental rights by the VDOE


Opposed

The proposed policies articulate views – such as the view that “Gender identity is considered an innate characteristic that most children declare by age five to six” – that are far different from those of many parents. Through its blanket endorsement of views like these, the VDOE has gone far beyond the path the General Assembly prescribed. Schools have a duty to protect the bodily privacy and dignity of all students. No child should be forced to share showers, locker rooms, hotel rooms or other intimate settings with a member of the opposite biological sex. Many children would feel uncomfortable when they encounter a member of the opposite sex – particularly adults – in gendered facilities or when entering a shared hotel room as part of an overnight school activity. Children, particularly adolescents, can experience hypersensitive and traumatic reactions to these situations. Schools should not be accommodating the especially harmful view that youth is an appropriate time to be encouraging, in some cases, irreversible “gender transitions”. The model regulations infringe the First Amendment rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The Department’s proposed policies would pit children against their parents when it comes to important questions about sex and gender identity.


Cutting out parents harms families

Any policies that is open to ignoring or dismissing parents runs counter to schools' mission of supporting students. Supporting discord between a student and parents harms the family and parent-child relationship.  Parents should be fully informed at all times, doing otherwise infringes on the parents' First Amendment rights Additionally, young children should not be forced to share restrooms, locker rooms, and overnight accommodations with some of the opposite biological sex. There is a hightened risk of trauma in those situations.


Gender identity doesn't belong in elementary school

All, It is psychologically confusing to teach a child the biology of male and female in the animal kingdom and then imply that this only applies to every animal except humans. Elementary age children play doctor, house, and other forms of imagination play as they learn the roles in society. They even play as other animals. This doesn't mean they identify as that animal in later years. Therefore we have no business pushing children to identify as the opposite sex simply because they played at it trying to understand it. Let children be children and keep sex out of it.


I fully support inclusive schools

I completely support making our schools more inclusive and supportive of LBGT youth. The other comments made here are reflective of exactly why this needs to happen - they are steeped in fear and misinformation. As a parent I can give my child and other children in our state no greater gift than showing them that schools are a safe place where kindness and understanding lead.


Strongly oppose

This is utter nonsense. Since when does an elementary age child have the full capacity to make this decision. And if you permit this to occur, I cannot even imagine what my grandson would feel like when a person who was born as a female who pretends to be a male, and wishes to use his restroom or locker room. This is just another way of destroying the family structure that our Lord created. A man and a woman to procreate. Not those who wish to be a man or woman.


Oppose transgender policy from VA Department of Education

I urge the VA Department of Education not to enact transgender policies. People who have gender dysphoria and identify as transgender should be treated with compassion and respect, but these policies do not do those things and will infringe on the rights and protections of others, especially the most vulnerable. I believe the issue surrounding bathroom and dressing room usage should be done on a case by case basis instead of imposing it on everyone. The truth is that there are only two sexes, and people with gender identity disorder should seek support and therapy to accept their biological sex.


treatment of transgender in schools

opposed! this hurts children


I oppose any legislation that lessens parental power

I oppose any laws that diminish parental power over decisions made for children.